A lamplit archive reading room overlooking the open prairie

For book clubs

How to Plan an Online Mystery Night for Your Book Club

All guides

By Tekeyla Friday Studios · Spoiler-free reading

Your next book-club conversation could begin with a sealed archive instead of a final chapter. A digital mystery gives readers something familiar—characters, atmosphere and competing interpretations—with a different invitation: bring a theory, compare the evidence, and let the group challenge your assumptions.

Choose an investigation, not a performance

An online investigation suits a group that loves discussing what a story means. The Cursed Archives is a browser-based, 31-day murder mystery from Tekeyla Friday Studios. Letters, documents and puzzles provide material for your conversation without asking your club to stage a costumed role-playing party.

Think of the gathering as a discussion alongside the game, not a separate multiplayer mode or a hosted event included in the ticket. Members can compare their ideas in person or through the video-call service your club already uses.

Set a shared stopping point

Before the first meeting, agree which available day or set of materials everyone will discuss. A shared stopping point keeps enthusiastic readers from accidentally revealing later discoveries. Let members catch up before moving the conversation forward.

A one-month pass gives the club a clear window for the investigation. You could plan an opening discussion, a mid-investigation check-in and a final theory session. These are suggested club gatherings, not promised live sessions supplied by the game.

Bring Prairie Gothic to the table

You do not need elaborate decorations. A reading lamp, a few old books and a notebook can suggest the archive’s mood: warm light against a wide, quiet prairie; orderly shelves with something unsettling just beyond view.

Keep the setting evocative rather than revealing. A closed folder is a better invitation than a display of game evidence. Do not print character case files or label anyone by their role in the mystery before the group has reached that discovery.

Ask questions that keep the mystery open

The strongest conversation separates what the group knows from what it believes. Give each reader a moment to explain a theory before inviting disagreement.

  • Which detail changed your first impression?
  • What have we actually observed, and what are we assuming?
  • Can the same piece of information support two different explanations?
  • What question would you ask next, without looking ahead?

Give readers and puzzle-solvers equal room

Some members will notice wording; others will enjoy reconstructing a scrambled photograph. Invite both kinds of observation. Comparing how people reached a conclusion can be more interesting than voting on who has the best theory.

Keep your club’s notes in your usual shared notebook or discussion space. Mark the agreed stopping point prominently, and avoid posting screenshots or answers publicly. Future players deserve the same surprise your club is enjoying.

Budget for the Game Pass

The home-page Game Pass is $15 CAD: a one-time payment for one month, including one complete mystery for 31 days. There is no recurring payment. For example, six members each buying their own pass would spend $90 CAD in total on passes.

That calculation is not a group ticket or a shared-account offer. Arrange each participating player’s access individually. Chinook Regional Library patrons can also review the separate free library-code option on the home page if they have an eligible access code.

The Cursed Archives runs year-round and can be played from anywhere in Canada. Choose your passes, agree on your first discussion checkpoint and let the theories begin.

Your invitation to the archive

One mystery. $15 CAD.

One-time payment · 1 month · One complete mystery for 31 days · No recurring payment

Choose your Game Pass